This was the ideal time — politically and policy-wise — for the California Legislature and the governor to authorize loads of extra spending on wildfire prevention and helping victims. But they botched it.
Shame on them.
The people’s representatives couldn’t get their act together amid internal turmoil to agree on a stripped-down $500-million wildfire appropriation before they were forced by law to adjourn the two-year legislative session at midnight Aug. 31.
The shelved wildfire bill was just one of several very important measures that were victimized by legislators fractured by rivalries and bitterness, and a governor apparently spread too thin managing a pandemic and infernos to exert his political muscle in the Legislature.
Other major bills that were scuttled — some even without a vote — involved housing production, police reform and broadband expansion for schoolchildren forced to attend classes from home.
It was the most discombobulated end of a legislative session — putting it politely — in the memory of everyone I talked to. It certainly was for me, and I’ve covered dozens.
“It was a hard year — the worst year I can remember to get things done,” says Senate President Pro Tem Toni Atkins, D-San Diego, a former Assembly speaker. “The pandemic didn’t help.”
What happened? Many things, according to legislators and aides, some of whom asked for anonymity because they feared offending colleagues.
Start with COVID-19. Because the Legislature tried to follow state public health guidelines, lawmakers couldn’t “work” the chamber floors as they normally do, persuading and dealing.
No face-to-face camaraderie — not even mask to mask. Physical distancing was strictly observed. Seatmates weren’t even allowed. All that made for difficult legislating.
There has always been tension between the Assembly and Senate, but the bad blood was abnormally poisonous this time. Many believe it started when the two houses couldn’t agree on uniform rules for remote debating and voting on bills.
The Senate allowed for remote participation in floor action over Zoom. In fact, Democrats forced it on Republicans because one GOP member tested positive for the coronavirus. The Assembly leadership wouldn’t allow Zoom participation but permitted proxy voting for lawmakers considered to be at high risk for COVID-19. None wound up voting by proxy.
Lack of agreement on how to protect against the virus is what set off Assembly Speaker Anthony Rendon, D-Lakewood, and Atkins on their separate ways, ending in bitterness between two leaders who used to be close allies.
Rendon was accused by Atkins and other senators of “running out the clock” on the last night, preventing several major Senate bills from being voted on by the Assembly until it was too late for them to be passed before the midnight deadline.
One such bill was Atkins’ housing measure that would have allowed duplexes to be built on lots zoned for single-family homes. It wasn’t debated in the Assembly until late on the final night and didn’t pass that house until shortly before midnight. There was no time left for the Senate to approve the Assembly’s amendments.
I asked Atkins whether she thought Rendon had purposely run out the clock.
“I do,” she replied. “Clearly, sending the bill back over (to the Senate) at 11:57 p.m., I don’t know how else I’m supposed to take it.”
Especially one from the Senate leader. The speaker shouldn’t have to look at a list to know that a pro tem’s bill is a high priority.
Back to the wildfire bill:
This was the perfect time to pass it with the state ablaze north and south and dense smoke polluting the skies. Newsom and Senate Democrats had agreed to spend $500 million for such things as cooling centers, emergency shelters, warning systems, home-hardening projects and forest cleanup.
The governor would have had to set a bad precedent by using his emergency power to waive a state law that requires amendments to be in print 72 hours before a bill can be voted on for final passage. But under these horrific fire conditions, who would protest?
Rendon quashed the proposal, however.
“For me, $500 million out of the general fund without budget hearings doesn’t seem very democratic,” the speaker says.
Senators counter that the speaker was irked because he wasn’t in on the deal with the governor.
Some lawmakers think Newsom should call a special legislative session to pass wildfire and housing legislation.
The governor should forget about it until after the pandemic and legislators get their acts back together.
George Skelton is a Los Angeles Times columnist. © 2020 Los Angeles Times. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency.
Dan Carter was a reporter for nomad Labs, before becoming the lead editor. Dan has over forty bylines and has reported on countless stories concerning all things related to tech and science. Dan studied at CSUF.